Email Legal Hold: Understanding the Importance and Best Practices

Legal hold, also known as a litigation hold or preservation order, is a crucial process for organizations to prevent the spoliation (or destruction) of evidence that could be relevant in a legal proceeding. In the context of email, legal hold specifically refers to the preservation of email communications that may be subject to litigation or regulatory investigations.

Why Email Legal Hold Matters

Email has become the primary mode of communication in the business world, and as a result, it often contains valuable information that may be required in legal matters. According to 2019 report The Radicati Group, total number business consumer emails sent received per day expected reach 293.6 billion by the end of 2019, and this number is projected to continue rising. With such a staggering volume of emails being exchanged, it`s essential for organizations to have a robust legal hold process in place to preserve relevant email data.

Best Practices for Email Legal Hold

Implementing effective email legal hold practices requires careful planning and execution. The following are some best practices that organizations should consider:

Best Practice	Description
Establish Clear Policies	Organizations should have clear and well-documented policies outlining the legal hold process for email communications. Employees should be educated on their responsibilities in complying with these policies.
Use Automated Solutions	Utilizing email archiving and management solutions can automate the process of placing legal holds on relevant email data, thereby reducing the risk of human error.
Regular Monitoring and Updates	Regularly monitoring and updating the legal hold status of email data is essential to ensure that relevant information is preserved throughout the lifecycle of a legal matter.

Case Study: The Importance of Email Legal Hold

In case Zubulake v. UBS Warburg, plaintiff requested production emails evidence. UBS Warburg failed to preserve relevant email data, leading to sanctions and considerable additional expenses. This case underscored the significance of implementing proper email legal hold processes to avoid adverse legal consequences.

Email legal hold is a critical aspect of e-discovery and legal compliance for organizations. By understanding the importance of email legal hold and implementing best practices, businesses can effectively preserve and produce relevant email data in legal proceedings, ultimately reducing the risk of sanctions and costly consequences.

---

Top 10 Legal Questions About Email Legal Hold

Question	Answer
1. What is an email legal hold?	An email legal hold is a directive to preserve all email communications that may be relevant to a pending or anticipated legal matter. It is a crucial step in the e-discovery process, ensuring that potentially relevant evidence is not destroyed or altered.
2. When should an email legal hold be implemented?	An email legal hold should be implemented as soon as an organization reasonably anticipates litigation or when litigation is already pending. It is important to act promptly to prevent the spoliation of evidence.
3. Who is responsible for issuing an email legal hold?	The responsibility for issuing an email legal hold typically falls on the organization`s legal team or designated legal counsel. They are tasked with identifying the need for a legal hold and ensuring its proper implementation.
4. What are the consequences of failing to implement an email legal hold?	Failure to implement an email legal hold can result in severe sanctions by the court, including adverse inference instructions, monetary fines, or even case dismissal. It is crucial to take the legal hold process seriously.
5. How long should an email legal hold be in place?	The duration of an email legal hold varies depending on the specific legal matter. It should remain in place until the conclusion of the litigation or until the duty to preserve evidence no longer exists.
6. Can an email legal hold be issued for personal email accounts?	Yes, an email legal hold can be issued for personal email accounts if they are used for business purposes or are relevant to the legal matter at hand. It is essential to cast a wide net when identifying potentially relevant communications.
7. What steps should be taken to ensure compliance with an email legal hold?	Organizations should communicate the legal hold directive to all relevant employees, suspend any automated email deletion processes, and implement mechanisms to periodically monitor and enforce compliance with the legal hold.
8. Can an email legal hold be lifted?	An email legal hold can be lifted once the duty to preserve evidence no longer exists, such as after the conclusion of the litigation or when all potentially relevant data has been collected and preserved.
9. What are best practices for implementing an email legal hold?	Best practices include promptly identifying the need for a legal hold, documenting the scope of the hold, coordinating with IT to collect and preserve relevant data, and regularly reviewing and updating the legal hold as needed.
10. How can I ensure that an email legal hold is defensible in court?	To ensure that an email legal hold is defensible in court, organizations should maintain comprehensive documentation of the legal hold process, communicate clearly with relevant employees, and engage in good faith efforts to preserve potentially relevant evidence.

---

Legal Contract for Email Legal Hold

This agreement (“Agreement”) is made and entered into as of the effective date stated herein by and between the parties identified below.

Party 1	Party 2
[Party 1 Name]	[Party 2 Name]
[Party 1 Address]	[Party 2 Address]
[Party 1 Email]	[Party 2 Email]

Background

WHEREAS, Party 1 and Party 2 desire to enter into an agreement to outline the terms and conditions of email legal hold.

Agreement

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement as of the effective date stated above.

1. Definitions
1.1 “Email Legal Hold” means the preservation of all emails and electronic communications that may be relevant to a legal proceeding or investigation.

2. Legal Hold Obligations

Party 2 agrees to implement and maintain an email legal hold process to preserve all relevant emails and electronic communications. Party 2 shall take all necessary steps to prevent the destruction, alteration, or deletion of such emails for the duration of the legal hold period.

3. Compliance Laws

Both parties agree to comply with all applicable laws and regulations related to the preservation of electronic communications, including but not limited to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and any relevant state laws.

4. Termination Legal Hold

The legal hold shall remain in effect until such time as Party 2 is notified in writing by Party 1 that the legal hold has been terminated.

5. Governing Law

This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the state of [State], without regard to its conflict of law principles.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement as of the effective date first above written.

Party 1	Party 2
[Party 1 Name]	[Party 2 Name]
_____________________	_____________________
Signature	Signature
_____________________	_____________________
Date	Date